Sin City Recut-Extended DVD
• Actors: Mickey Rourke, Clive Owen, Bruce Willis, Jessica Alba, Devon Aoki • Directors: Frank Miller, Quentin Tarantino, Robert Rodriguez • Writers: Frank Miller • Producers: Bill Scott, Bob Weinstein, Elizabeth Avellan, Harvey Weinstein • Number of discs: 2
The two-disc edition of Sin City easily makes the earlier single-disc theatrical-cut release obsolete by including the regular theatrical cut on the first disc, recutting the movie into four extended segments on the second disc (separated by story line), then piling on an impressive load of bonus features. But there's a catch. Billed as "Recut, Extended, Unrated," with "over 20 minutes" of new footage, the new set's four separate stories are extended by only about 6.5 total minutes of movie action (see details below in "What's New"); the rest of the added running time is the splashy new title shots (named by the title of the story or book) and the four minutes of credits that run at the end of each segment. Each addition makes the movie even closer to the comic books, and these extended segments are generally preferable to the theatrical equivalents (unfortunately, there's no Play All option), but don't expect the same impact as Peter Jackson's Lord of the Rings extended editions. And although this version is unrated, the only risqué addition is a bit of violence from Miho that's no worse than the rest of the crazy violence in the film.
Included: Complete Sin City Graphic Novel - The Hard Goodbye
Special Features Commentary by Robert Rodriguez & Frank Miller Commentary by Robert Rodriguez & Quentin Tarantino Commentary by Austin premiere audience reaction Recut and extended theatrical release - separated into four stories Original theatrical release including: All-new feature commentary with Robert Rodriguez & Frank Miller All-new feature commentary with Robert Rodriguez & Quentin Tarantino All-new feature commentary of Austin premiere audience reaction Exclusive never-before-seen extras: 15-minute film school with Robert Rodriguez The movie in high-speed green screen The Long Take: 17 uninterrupted minutes of Tarantino's segment Sin City Night at Antones -- filmmakers, cast and crew party 10-minute cooking school with Robert Rodriguez Bloopers Teaser & theatrical trailers A Hard Top With a Decent Engine: The cars of Sin City Making the Monsters: Special effects make-up Trench Coats & Fishnets: The costumes of Sin City Booze, Broads & Guns: The props of Sin City How it Went Down: Convincing Frank Miller to make the film Giving the Characters Life: Casting the film Special guest director: Quentin Tarantino Sin-Chroni-City interactive game
How Are the Bonus Features? Robert Rodriguez has always loved DVDs, so the bonus features are extensive. On the first disc, there is somehow room for the theatrical cut of the film with its DTS track (the extended versions have only Dolby 5.1), two commentary tracks, an alternate audio track with a live audience in Austin, Texas, an interactive map of characters and locations, and 47 minutes of featurettes covering Frank Miller, Quentin Tarantino, cars, costumes, props, and special effects. The first commentary is Rodriguez and Miller discussing the concepts and the cast. The second commentary is mostly by Rodriguez, but Tarantino drops in briefly for the scene he directed (with Clive Owen and Benicio Del Toro in the car), as does an enthusiastic Bruce Willis for his segment. The Tarantino scene gets a lot of attention on the second disc as well, in a 14-minute take in which he can be heard coaching the actors. Also on the disc are Rodriguez's usual "flic school (among the topics is how scenes were created by merging footage of actors who never actually met), footage of Bruce Willis's band performing in Austin at the time of the shooting, and another Rodriguez cooking school (this time it's breakfast tacos). But the most interesting feature is the "green screen version" of the film: the entire film as it was shot in front of the green screen, sped up to play in only 12 minutes. You can see the actors (in color!) interacting only with the props and each other. Last, there's a DVD-sized complete comic book of The Hard Goodbye. What's New in the Extended Version? "The Customer Is Always Right" (the opening sequence with Josh Hartnett and Marley Shelton) has no new footage, but now goes straight into the one-minute epilogue with Hartnett and Alexis Bledel that closed the theatrical cut. "The Hard Goodbye" (with Mickey Rourke as "Marv" ) has two new sequences totaling about two minutes: Marv encounters his mother and finds his gun, and talks to Weevil in the club. In "The Big Fat Kill" (with Clive Owen and Benicio Del Toro), some short dialogue is restored, along with another wicked slice by Miho (Devon Aoki)--about a minute total. "That Yellow Bastard" (with Bruce Willis and Jessica Alba) has about 3.5 new minutes: there are more visitors to Hartigan's hospital bed, including his wife and a nurse; Carla Gugino's Lucille character comes to assist Hartigan when he wants to get out of jail (probably the best addition); and Mr. Shlubb and Mr. Klump have some more lines. --David Horiuchi